Have you ever opened a drawer you hadn't touched in years and felt like you were looking at a stranger's things?
Except they were yours. Every single one.
That happened to me on an ordinary Sunday. I was hunting for a spare set of batteries, and I ended up in the bottom drawer of the dresser in our spare room. The one I never open. (I'd forgotten what was even in there.)
Inside was a lanyard from a job I left over a decade ago. A pair of reading glasses I don't wear anymore. A little planner I bought the year I swore I'd finally get organized. And a folded church bulletin from an Easter I couldn't even place.
I sat down on the edge of the bed and held that lanyard for a minute.
None of it was worth anything. But I couldn't put it back either.
Because that drawer wasn't holding old things. It was holding old versions of me. The woman who wore that lanyard every day. The woman who was sure she'd use that planner. They were still in there, tucked away, taking up room I'd stopped thinking about years ago.
A lot of us do this without noticing. We fill our homes with the people we used to be, and we never stop to ask if we still need them there.
Letting go of sentimental items you've outgrown is harder than tossing junk. Because it feels like letting go of yourself.
But I've learned it isn't. And that spare-room drawer was where it started.
Our Things Hold On to Who We Used to Be
I always thought decluttering was about the stuff. The extra mugs, the clothes that don't fit, the gadgets I never use. Clear those out and you're done.
But some things are harder to touch than others. And it took me a while to understand why.
It's because they're not really about the object at all. They're about who I was when that object was part of my daily life.
The lanyard wasn't a lanyard. It was me at 52, rushing out the door with my coffee, part of a world I don't belong to anymore. The planner wasn't a planner. It was the version of me who was so sure that this would be the year everything got organized.
When I hold something like that, I'm not deciding whether to keep an item. I'm deciding whether to let go of a person. And that person is me.
That's why it feels so heavy. Your head knows it's just an old thing in a drawer. But your heart feels like you're throwing away a piece of yourself.
I've written before about what it feels like to outgrow the things you used to love. This is close to that, but a little different. These weren't things I loved and lost interest in. They belonged to a me who doesn't exist anymore.
And keeping them all in a drawer doesn't bring her back. It just keeps me holding onto a life I've already left. (I didn't see that for years.)
Every Drawer Held a Different Chapter of My Life
Once I noticed it in that one drawer, I started seeing it everywhere. Not junk. Old versions of me, tucked into corners all over the house.
I found five of them. Five women I used to be, each one still taking up space I could give to the woman I am now.
The job I left behind
I worked the same job for almost twenty years. When I left, I boxed up more than I realized.
The lanyard was just the start. There was an old name badge, a coffee mug from a work trip, and a stack of thank-you notes from people I barely remember now. I even kept a folder of my old projects, like someone might one day ask to see them.
Nobody ever did. And I never opened that folder once.
I kept it because that job was a big part of who I was for a long time. Letting the box go felt like saying that part of my life didn't matter.
But it did matter. It still does. The box leaving doesn't change that. I did that work. I don't need a mug to prove it.
The hobby I keep meaning to get back to
I have a bin of scrapbooking supplies in the closet. Nice ones, too. Paper, stickers, the special scissors, all of it.
I bought them during a stretch when I was really into it. Then life got busy, the bin went in the closet, and that was about eight years ago.
Every time I saw it, I told myself I'd get back to it. Someday.
The truth is, I'm not that person right now. And that's okay. I read more these days. I take walks. My afternoons look different than they did back then.
Holding onto that bin didn't make me a scrapbooker. It just made me feel a little guilty every time I opened the closet. The same thing happens with the books we swear we'll read one day. If you have a stack like that, my honest take on decluttering books might help.
The years the kids still lived at home
This is the one that got me.
I have a drawer full of things from when my kids were young. Not the special keepsakes I set aside on purpose. Just stuff. A macaroni craft. A single tiny sock. A birthday card with handwriting I'd know anywhere.
My kids are grown now. They have their own homes and their own lives. (One of them called while I was sitting there holding that little sock, which felt about right.)
I wasn't keeping those things for them. They don't even know that drawer exists. I was keeping them for me. For the woman who had a house full of noise and little shoes by the door.
I loved that time. I miss it some days. But I found out my kids don't want most of what I'd been saving anyway, which I wrote about here. A drawer of it doesn't give me those years back. Being their mom still does.
The clothes for the woman I thought I'd become
We all have these. The clothes for a life we thought we'd be living by now.
I had a blazer I bought for a fancier version of myself. Heels for the parties I imagined we'd throw. A dress two sizes too small that I swore I'd fit into again.
Every time I opened that part of the closet, those clothes had something to say to me. And it wasn't kind.
They reminded me of who I thought I'd be, and made me feel bad about who I actually am. That's a lot to ask of a closet.
When I finally let them go, the closet felt lighter. So did I. If yours is full of a woman you thought you'd become, here's how I downsized my wardrobe without the regret.
The person who hosted every holiday
For years, our house was the house. Every Thanksgiving, every Christmas, everyone came to me.
I had the big platters, the extra folding chairs, and the tablecloth that seated twelve. I had two of some things, just in case.
We don't host like that anymore. The family takes turns now, and I like it. But I was still storing enough serving dishes for a crowd I no longer cook for.
Keeping all of it didn't make me the hostess I used to be. It just filled my cabinets with a job I've happily handed off. So I kept a few favorites. The rest went to a young couple at church who are just starting out.
What Helped Me Loosen My Grip
I didn't clear all of this out in a weekend. It took months, and a few false starts.
What helped most was changing the question I asked. I stopped asking “do I still want this?” The answer was always a soft maybe, and maybe keeps everything.
Instead I asked, “does the woman I am today need this?” That one's easier to answer. It's honest. And it puts me in charge instead of the drawer. Those kinds of honest questions changed how I make these decisions.
The other thing that helped was letting the memory stay while the object went.
I didn't need the whole box from my old job. I kept one thank-you note that meant something and let the rest go. I didn't need the full bin of scrapbook supplies. I kept the two pages I'd already finished and gave away the paper and the stickers.
The memory isn't in the mug. It's not in the tiny sock or the too-small dress. It's in me. It always was. Taking a photo of something before it goes is plenty, most of the time.
I also gave myself permission to feel a little sad about it. Letting go of who you used to be comes with a small ache, and that's normal. Letting go of sentimental items is never really about the item. It's about making peace with time passing. So I'd hold the thing, remember her, and then let it go.
Some days I could only do one drawer. That was fine. One drawer at a time is how they filled up. So one drawer at a time is how I emptied them.
The Woman I Am Now Deserves the Room
Here's what surprised me most.
I thought letting go of those things would feel like losing myself. It felt like the opposite.
Every drawer I cleared made a little more room for who I am today. Not who I was at that job. Not the scrapbooker, or the holiday hostess, or the young mom with little shoes by the door. All of them are still part of me. They just don't need a drawer anymore.
The woman I am now reads in the afternoon, takes her walks, and calls her grandkids on Sundays. She deserves space in her own home. She shouldn't have to share every closet with five versions of who she used to be.
You are allowed to change. You're allowed to keep the memory and release the thing. And you're allowed to make room for the woman you are today, instead of the one you used to be.
Start with one drawer. See how it feels.
I think you'll be surprised too.
Ready to Make Room for Who You Are Now?
Clearing out old versions of yourself is tender work, and it's a lot easier with a plan in your hand. My free Declutter for Self Care Checklist walks you through your home at a pace that won't wear you out, so you can release what no longer fits the woman you've become.
It's gentle, it's doable, and it meets you right where you are today.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is it so hard to let go of sentimental items?
Sentimental items are hard to release because they're tied to who you were when you got them, not just to the object itself. Letting one go can feel like letting go of a version of yourself. That's why an old lanyard or a child's craft can feel heavier than anything expensive. Once you understand that's what's happening, the deciding gets a little easier.
How do I let go of things from a job or role I've left?
Start by reminding yourself that the work you did still counts, whether or not you keep the mug. Try keeping one small thing that truly means something, like a single thank-you note, and let the rest go. The memory of that time lives with you, not in a box in the closet. You don't need proof of who you were.
What should I do with clothes I keep for a body or life I don't have anymore?
Be honest about who those clothes are really for. If they're for a version of you that hasn't shown up in years, they're taking up space and making you feel bad every time you see them. Keep what fits and suits the woman you are now. Letting the rest go usually makes the whole closet feel lighter.
How do I keep the memory without keeping the clutter?
Take a photo of the item before it leaves, or keep one small piece from a larger collection. A single page from an old hobby, one card from a stack, one dish from a full set. The memory isn't stored in the object, so you don't lose it when the object goes. Most people find the photo is more than enough.
Where do I even start when everything feels sentimental?
Start with one drawer, not a whole room. Pick a small space and ask one question about each item: does the woman I am today need this? Work for as long as you have energy, then stop. One drawer at a time is a fine pace, and it adds up faster than you'd think.
Follow me elsewhere!
